Device care

Why Mobile Device Propositions and Programs Now Carry More Risk per Handset

MCE staff

Contact us

Global smartphone shipments fell 19 percent in the third quarter, yet revenue rose three percent, according to Counterpoint Research. That means the average selling price rose roughly 27 percent, to $442.

Higher prices make financing, trade-in and refurbished phones more attractive to customers, but they also carry longer upgrade cycles, raising the stakes for communications service providers (CSPs). Each handset represents more money, so an overvalued trade-in, unnecessary return or a customer whose device issue remains unaddressed can lead to higher costs and losses. Tracking how many devices move through these programs tells only part of the story. Providers in Canada and the UK also need to understand how much money is at risk on each device and subscriber.

Per-device risk exposure with common device strategy practices

Upgrade rates, trade-in volumes and the number of devices financed show how much activity a provider’s programs generate. They do not show what mistakes cost. As handset values rise, overpaying for trade-ins or accepting an avoidable return can mean a larger loss per device. The impact will vary by market and device mix, but tracking volumes gives providers a partial picture of that risk.

The size of each error ultimately comes down to what the provider knows about the handset at the moment it prices it. The customer knows whether the battery holds a charge and whether the screen has a fault, but the provider usually objectively doesn’t. Economists call this gap information asymmetry, and it produces a familiar outcome in used-goods markets: when buyers cannot verify condition, they discount every item to cover the worst ones, or they pay the average and absorb the losses. 

A trade-in program faces the same choice. Generous values on unverified condition lead the warehouse to regrade the device downward later.  Variance on evaluations can run as high as 30-40 percent, costing dozens of dollars per device for a few million devices annually. Cautious values send the customer to another buyer in frustration. Higher prices widen both the overpayment and the lost sale. 

With remorse returns, the losses can be higher, with MCE Systems internal data showing that as high as 40 percent of returns are No Fault/Trouble Found. In an attempt to appease customers, reps often provide a new device without a thorough, objective assessment, costing providers up to tens of millions of dollars per year in unqualified claim acceptances.

Device care as a churn risk

With customers keeping their phones longer than they used to, upgrade cycles are expected to eventually lengthen. Already consumers are keeping their phones for up to five years now as quality improves, which will likely extend upgrade cycles to three or four years in the long run. Currently, MCE Systems research shows 1 in 3 customers faces a device issue over a two-year period.  When these do occur, the provider’s NPS drops by 19 points and a further 36 if the provider doesn’t resolve it. In the event of an extended upgrade cycle, the risk of a device issue increases. When presented with a strong upgrade offer near the end of their existing upgrade cycle, a customer with any device issue is at a high risk to switch. This puts an emphasis on device health management for the provider throughout the device lifecycle – to have insight into the customer’s device performance on a regular basis and know when to engage with an upgrade.

Objective condition data turns exposure into a measured quantity

Providers can narrow the information gap at the point of valuation, warranty claim assessment and device health or care management by reading conditions from the handset itself: battery health, diagnostic results, performance and software state, in the app or in store. MCE Systems has and can aid providers across these risks around the device:

Trade-in

When implemented with Vodafone, MCE Systems’ app-led trade-in solution reduced variance on device evaluations from 30 percent to less than three, without compromising on customer satisfaction (NPS boost of 17 points in the process).

Warranty claim management

In a warehouse test on devices who’d been approved for warranty claims but not unqualified (no fault/trouble found) in the provider’s store, MCE Systems found it could have deflected 81 of them had the reps had the device diagnostic assessment technology.

Device care

MCE Systems can extract mobile device intelligence in customer troubleshooting scenarios, proactive opportunistic device health checks and background telemetry monitoring to evaluate which customers’ device performance warrants a well-timed upgrade offer.

A market with higher risk

The third-quarter data describes a market where each device that does move carries more value than before. For providers, the lasting question concerns how precisely a program prices the condition of every handset passing through it, because that precision now decides the margin on each transaction. Providers that want to see how device condition data has worked inside trade-in, claim management and care programs, can read more here.

One Platform. Every Touchpoint.

MCE is the AI-native experience layer for telcos, connecting legacy systems, real-time data, and intelligent workflows to power every customer interaction.

Copyright © 2026 MCE Systems Ltd. All Rights Reserved.